What constitutes a good song?

• Good production, instrumentation, lyricism, meaning, vocal performance, vibe, replayability
• song criteria is good.

What constitutes a good album?

• Cohesiveness, songs must sound different, a good theme is great (is one required?), and interludes, skits, intros, and instrumentals all contribute to an album's dynamic ability and flow.
• album criteria is flawed
• If an album has a bunch of great songs, but does not flow well, has no theme, what is the highest it can be graded? (Ex. Astroworld?)
• can an album be good, or even great, without a common theme? Does that make a good theme the factor that takes an album from great to generational?
• How do you rate a theme from 0-5?

If an album has a similar feel, theme, and sound, does that make it a good album or static?

• Is “Dynamic” a good criterion?

Do songs ever sound the same?